Born 1767, died 1860 - the documented root of the McAnally/McAnnally family, whose descendants are buried across Guinns Cove, Hogeland, and Elvester cemeteries. His son, Elijah McAnally Jr., extended the family into Hogeland Cemetery specifically.
Appears in: Guinns Cove Cemetery, Hogeland Cemetery, and Elvester Cemetery.
Notable descendants:
- Elijah McAnally Jr. (1804-1869) - son, who extended the family into Hogeland Cemetery.